Tips for Indians to agree or disagree a marriage proposal? What counts more - age,education, financial status or ...

76

By premsingh

It is said that marriages are made in heaven. In India, marriages are made in hotels, communities halls and farm houses. I am saying all this because majority of marriages in India are still arranged marriages and these are arranged by parents of both sides. Surprisingly, arranged marriages are more successful and happier than love marriages. In such marriages consents of the both girl and boy are sought before finalizing these marriages. However, a decade back it was customary not to seek the consent of either boy or girl going to marry. Logic for success in such marriages is mainly considered to be matching criterias like age, education, family background etc. In love marriages such considerations are given less weightage or even ignored. Love marriages are considered successful in the begining but later on majority of such marriages results in breaking of relationship.

Proverbs and sayings about marriage:

Marriages are best made of dissimilar material.
- Theodore Parker

A happy marriage is a new beginning of life, a new starting-point for happiness and usefulness.
- A. P. Stanley

The ideal that marriage aims at is that of spiritual union through the physical. The human love that it incarnates is intended to serve as a stepping stone to divine or universal love.
- Mohandas K. Gandhi

A good marriage is one which allows for change and growth in the individuals and the way they express their love.
- Pearl S. Buck

In a successful marriage, there is no such thing as one's way. There is only the way of both, only the bumpy, dusty, difficult, but always mutual path.
- Phyllis McGinley

Where there's marriage without love, there will be love without marriage.
- Benjamin Franklin

Choose your wife as you wish your children to be.
- Gaelic Proverb

By all means marry; if you get a good wife, you'll become happy; if you get a bad one, you'll become a philosopher.
- Socrates


Irrespective of mode of marriage, the most important question is what points need to be considered before saying yes or no to a marriage proposal? Criteria may differ, however, depending on your gender. If you are a girl, you have limited options with you, at least in developing countries like India or Pakistan. You are lucky if you are a boy but freedom or advantage of being a male should not get you in a fix over the time (being in the state of indecisiveness). I've observed in several cases, the prospective boys and girll became overage due to their sky high expectations. Since the matter is very crucial, we'll discuss all the points carefully (Most of discussion in this hub is in Indian context).

1. Physical appearance: In case of arranged marriages, preference to select a candidate (girl) for marriage always rests with the parents or relatives of the male candidate. Case may be reverse also if family of the girl has higher social status than the boy's family. It won't be out of context here to inform that young girls and boys in India are more sentimental compared to other countries as they are great fan of bollywood movies and they always try to match the appearance of would be husband or wife with the film actors or actresses. While trying to find a match similar in appearance to their favorite hero or heroine, they end up rejecting a score of girls or boys in the screening process. A time comes after few years, when they have to settle for an inferior match. This raise the most important argument for discussion. Is the external appearance of a girl or boy so important? The answer to this question after lot of discussion emerges something like this: Don't look for extra-ordinary beauty. Their must always be a match of everything otherwise problems like "cheating wife" or cheating husband arises.

2. Color:Try to marry with the candidate of matching color. Appearance or looks should also be matching to live happily. There are always exceptions and one may find husband and wife of contrasting skin colors living happily together. So, try to have a match, if possible.

3. Height: Matching height is the most important criteria that must be borne in mind while finding a match. Best match is one where girl height is 2-3" short than the boy. Girl should never be taller than the boy.

4. Physique: Although physique of both male and female is likely to change after marriage or after birth of children, it's better if both girl and boy are either slim or obese .However, problems have been reported in child birth (conceiving) if both husband and wife are obese.

5. Age: Results of a study on marriage and divorce were published few days back. Study conducted by researchers at Bath University found that a woman, with superior education, marrying a man five or more years older made them a happy couple. This conclusion holds good for people belonging to both developed and developing countries. This is true in all senses and applicable to Indian couples also. However, difference between man and woman should not be more than 8-10 years otherwise it would lead to divorce or separation. Chances of separations are more if a woman id older than the man. Study also revealed that such couples are three times or more as likely to divorce then they were the same age group. Hence, couples belonging to same age group have more chances to lead a happy and stable life.

Express your views, these may help future genearations make a decision

Which of the marriage type may lead to a happy and long relationship?

  • Love Marriage
  • Arrange Marriage
  • A mix of both
See results without voting

6. Education: Study suggested that there were more chances of stable married life if woman was more educated than man. In Indian conditions, education of woman did not matter few years back but now things are changing. There is a change in thinking of people. Earlier,male dominated society did not favor the idea of woman doing a job outside her home. However, it is getting difficult day by day to provide good facility and education to children if man is the only earning member of the house. Hence, an educated male would prefer to have an educated wife. If both husband and wife belong to same field of education, it make them a perfect couple.


Financial status of in-laws influences the fututure of a marriage. What's your opinion?

  • Families of both woman and man should have same financial status
  • Woman's family should be financially stroonger
  • Man's family should be financially stronger
  • Financial status does'nt make any difference
See results without voting

What should be the age difference between a wife and husband for a happy marriage

  • Wife should be 5 year older than husband
  • Husband should be 5 year older than wife
  • Both should be of same age group
  • Age difference does not matter
See results without voting

7. Family background: If both male and female are from similar background (financially and socially), there are more chances of a stable and happeir married life compared to couple belonging to dissimilar background. If husband belongs to a greedy family then wife belonging to financially sound family had more chances of a comfortable life at in-laws house. If she belongs to a poor family, she shall always be teased for her family background. However, this all depends on the understanding of husband. If he is a practical man and has longsightedness, he can manage the things in future.

8. Adjusting nature: This is the important attribute. If both husband and wife has adjusting nature and always ready to compromise, more chances of a happier married life exist. If any of them is greedy and never ready to compromise, life of both may become hell in the future. Hence, give most of the point (weightage) to this aspect. It would take care of rest of things.

9. Other factors: Married life is likely to be happeir if both are bachelors and first timers or both are divorcee. If only one among two has been a divorcee, than chances of survival of relationship becomes dim.

Comments

premsingh profile image

premsingh Hub Author 2 months ago

Dear Mohit, my heart says you should marry with your gf but mind says your love attachment may not last long after 10-15 years. If you think your world revolves around your gf, go ahead and marry her. Also discuss it with cool mind with the girl and give her some time to think over it. I'm surprised why girl is willing to marry with a boy 5 year younger to her. I could be wrong also as girl is really in love with you.

mohit 2 months ago

my girl friend is 30 and i'm 25. i really love her and both understanding is so good but my family is not accept my g.f for marriage because age difference but i want to marry her. so please give me right advise it's my last decision i'm very nervous fell always this matter what can i do this time (love marriage , arrange ) but my mother ...... is not satisfy but i'm totally satisfy

premsingh profile image

premsingh Hub Author 3 months ago

If you think you can not live without your bf, go ahead, make marriage and forget all the criteria mentioned above. Living without love is difficult to imagine.

Ivy 3 months ago

I also agree you..ya bf should be elder for minimum of 4 yrs..but we really love each other very much why this problem is their in our lives??? I dont know what to do....what will be good for us??... I m really in tension...please help me out....

premsingh profile image

premsingh Hub Author 3 months ago

Ideally bf should be elder by 4-5 years as per the opinion poll on this hub but this is not any hard and fast rule.Females get older early than males that's why age difference of 4-5 years is desirable. This is particularly desirable for male dominated societies.

Ivy 3 months ago

Hi...me and my bf are of same year and he is only 24 days elder to me, will their be any problem for us later when we are married? And will their be any sexual problem later?

premsingh profile image

premsingh Hub Author 4 months ago

thanks ishwaryaa22. I am really happy with your active participation at hubpages. You have got all the talents and zeal to become a successful hubber.I frequently come to your hubs to find interesting information.

ishwaryaa22 profile image

ishwaryaa22 Level 7 Commenter 4 months ago

Most of the factors listed by you above are true in most cases. I agree with u. It is compatibility that counts the most in all cases. Good and knowledgeable hub! Thank u for sharing. Vote up.

premsingh profile image

premsingh Hub Author 4 months ago

It may be true Sanjay. Age may not matter much in majority of cases but impact may vary with increasing age difference.

Kelly thanks for views expressed about the ground realities in some countries. Divorce rate & relationship may vary with geographical boundaries.

Kelly 4 months ago

My opinion is that success of any marriage cannot be measured by divorce rate!! Never. In my country we have special organization called :"Every fifth woman". It was formed as initiative based on the statistics that every fifth woman may be trated not well, physically or psychically opressed or abused. I think in many countries with low divorce rate , to express the number of women treated not well by their husbands, the name of alliance would be :"every second woman" or even maybe " every woman".

What does divorce rate say ? Is it not also about status of the woman in the society ? What are her chances to get incorporated into social life, if she gets divorced ,... how the law formulates rights for divorced woman on the property they have with her husband in marriage ( maybe even fact SHE CANNOT consider anything in marriage to be also her part explains a lot.. )...ets. I think that if society does not gives chances to divorced woman, than of course also divorce rate is lower and woman will in marriage suffer whatever not to loose the status... In this sence yes, it is very much of cultural thing than some moral feature of the married couple. And many other things. So - what is divorce rate ?

sanjay 5 months ago

i like all points except age. i have seen lots of couple with big age difference whose married life is good.

premsingh profile image

premsingh Hub Author 6 months ago

In love, all these parameters become worthless.Love is said to be blind. In real love people don't give any weight-age to materialistic things.

rohit 6 months ago

hi....can it is possible to marry taller girl than a boy...if any boy loves a girl who is taller than a boy and that girl is also like him then what should they do ?????

premsingh profile image

premsingh Hub Author 7 months ago

thanks Sunithea, Neo, Vera, and Anil for giving valuable feedback and opinion on this important issue. Sunithaea may be true that family of the females are prohibited by customs from seeing divorce. Some restrictions need to be there for both sides.

I also agree with views of Anil. I have given ideal points for consideration. If both sides agree to it then it's no more an issue.

anil 7 months ago

criteria of height is not well justified,mutual understanding is very important in every relatioship

Anil 11 months ago

Good read for All who are married and yet to be

Vera 17 months ago

I love dis, cudos 2 u guys 4 d job wel done

Neo 19 months ago

thanks for such useful information

sunithaea 2 years ago

We cannot say that Indian culture helps to prevent the number of divorce cases, what I think , on the contrary it prohibits women/family from seeking divorce in the name of culture. There are lots of women who suffer under marriage but due to this culture and tradition issues, they are sort of reluctant to seek divorce even if it is an abusive relationship.

premsingh profile image

premsingh Hub Author 2 years ago

Yes, Indian culture is largely responsible for least divorces in India. This is covered under arranged marriage because arranged marriage was the Indian culture in the past.

H P Roychoudhury profile image

H P Roychoudhury 2 years ago

Hi,

No doubt the hub is a good one out of good research but I like to add culture is also a factor in the long lasting of marriage. It is because number of divorce in India is less compare to Western Countries; it may be due to Indian culture.

premsingh profile image

premsingh Hub Author 2 years ago

thanks to both creativeone59 and PegCole17. Your happy married life pegCole supports the findings of study. You're right concept of dual income is gaining momentum.

PegCole17 profile image

PegCole17 Level 7 Commenter 2 years ago

Enjoyed this hub a lot! The age difference of 5 years is a pretty successful gap, of course I would say this as it is the case in my happy marriage.

I find your comment really interesting: "Earlier, male dominated society did not favor the idea of woman doing a job outside her home. However, it is getting difficult day by day to provide good facility and education to children if man is the only earning member of the house."

Looks like the evolution of the dual income family is happening and this will really mess with the statistics.

creativeone59 profile image

creativeone59 2 years ago

Thank you so much for your wonderful hub, thank you for sharing it. creativeone59

premsingh profile image

premsingh Hub Author 2 years ago

This research has been conducted at Bath University on Swiss couples but it holds equally good in Indian conditions. I guess these findings are applicable to most of the the countries.

hubber-2009 profile image

hubber-2009 2 years ago

very nice research. will the age factor applies only to India or any couple in the world?

Submit a Comment
You Must Sign In To Comment

To comment on this Hub, you must sign in or sign up and post using a HubPages account.

Please wait working